• 0 Posts
  • 34 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 12th, 2023

help-circle



  • Just so we’re clear, your position is that Biden is at fault, but if he wasn’t supporting this genocide, it would actually be worse?

    It’s late, and I’m watching the fights, so I don’t have my full attention to spare, but I had enough available to read your comment and see that that you’re being earnest in your argument, and your analysis is not disingenuous.

    That’s important to me, because while it’s really bad, it also means that you’re probably not a bad person.

    For starters, it’s all counterfactuals, and while that alone means it’s a just barrel of formal and informal fallacies, it’s also based on deeply flawed, or just grossly uneducated, misunderstandings of a wide range of fields, ranging from international relations, to military procurement and sustainment.

    I’m not trying to be mean, and to be fair, I have an academic background in multiple fields related to these subjects, so I’m not pulling my criticism out of my ass.

    But another fight is about to start, so my text to speech comment must end.


  • No… what are you talking about?

    You said the escalatory actions were the Abraham accords, and moving the embassy to Jerusalem.

    I just pointed those were both actions taken by the Trump administration.

    So what requires a historical account? Do you mean you just want to site random historical events with no context, and if anyone points out when they happened, that’s somehow a bad faith argument, or an unfair standard to apply…?

    Oh my God… Did you really just read those “trigger events” in some article, have no idea what they actually were, or when they happened, but still decided to cite them in support of your argument…?




  • No, you just did whataboutism.

    Which is why I separated my other commentary, and addressed it in general, and not directly at you.

    Because while it’s related to your comment, you hadn’t crossed that bridge yet, but there’s no shortage of that in these comments, read up and down.

    Israel knows their client state, including the IDF and political leadership. Do you even read Israeli newspapers regularly?

    I’m well aware of AIPAC, and the extent of their lobbying and influence operations.

    None of that has anything to do with what I’ve been talking about.





  • …what? You just said Abraham accords are the reason for this conflict… That’s the same as saying Trump is to blame…

    And just because I’m rightfully assigning blame to Biden, the current sitting US president and self-proclaimed biggest support of Israel, doesn’t mean I support Trump.

    Feel free to creep on all of my comment history, my political leanings should be pretty self-evident.

    Don’t you feel gross telling people that if they say Biden’s policies have allowed the situation to get out of control, it means they support Trump?

    I mean, you do understand that ultimately Israel is our client state and entirely dependent upon our aid for their survival, right?

    They literally could not be prosecuting this war if we stopped shipping them weapons, and they would never have attacked Iran if we didn’t have our CSG and accompanying missile destroyers sitting in between them.







  • Yes, and that’s what Ukraine is doing at the moment. But they’re doing it in the cities like Moscow that actually matter to Putin, and the Russian elites.

    The comment I was responding to was talking about taking a lot small drones deeper into Russia, which are places that Putin couldn’t give a shit about.

    So, if they aren’t useful for destroying critical infrastructure, and Putin and the Russian elite don’t care about any psychological impact on those civilians, what is the point? Which is why I covered using them to target civilians, and why that would be a bad idea.

    Saboteurs and Ukrainian assets inside of Russia are not an unlimited resource. Wouldn’t it make more sense for them to use their time doing things that actually politically harm Putin, or impact the wider Russian war effort?