• 35 Posts
  • 647 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 12th, 2023

help-circle










  • At some point, western countries have to actually believe Netanyahu when he says there is not going to be a Palestinian state. The 2 state solution is dead. Israel has killed it with acts just like this. No amount of farcical recognition of the rump Bantustan in Ramallah is going to undo this.

    So it’s a simple matter of recognizing the reality that Israel is either going to be a Jewish state serving the fears of a Jewish diaspora or a democratic republic of the actual people, Arabs, Jews and others, who live under its law. It’s a simple choice, that the Israeli governments of the past twenty years have been etching in blood on the land.












  • You’re contradicting your own argument:

    It was never meant to remedy shitty living conditions.

    Vs

    Ask anyone with disabilities, abusive families, trauma, financial hardship, and generally going though too much shit in life and you’ll find that it was never about a lack of imagination.

    This is a contradiction. You are literally picking the antinatalist option because of shitty living conditions.

    And of course, the lack of imagination is not whether you can imagine things being better but whether you can imagine things becoming better starting from where we are here and now.

    =======

    We suffer because we are able to imagine how things could have been so much better. It is because we can imagine ourselves in a better place

    If you can imagine such a place, steelman your argument then, try making it without a premise of shitty living conditions. Pick a convivial world, and make an antinatalist argument from that world. Does it still stand?

    =======

    Finally, the argument that says nonexistence might be better is literally vacuous: False implies True. Nonexistence therefore is trivially whatever you want it to be, but not In any meaningful sense.